@StarMist - I lol'd at the "you don't have to respectfully disagree" statement. That made my morning :)
@QuickSciFi - awesome :) But we also want to make sure that the time and effort we put into this game will give a great experience.
I haven't played Lufia 1, but I did enjoy Lufia 2 a lot. Also, don't forget Tecmo's Secret of the Stars. That's an pretty bad ass RPG as well. Chrono Trigger used 256x224 (or whatever the SNES equivalent is), same with Secret of Mana and Secret of Evermore. The world map in Chrono Trigger uses a higher resolution (512 maybe?), but they did cut the vertical resolution a little bit, hence the black border showing on the bottom.
I also can't believe nobody mentioned Breath of Fire (Capcom), even though Square did have some involvement (I think publishing?).
As for voice acting - not gonna happen. If we were to move onto the Sega CD, or copy WM with the use of the sega cd (which we aren't, since that was a brilliant idea and I'd love for it to be exclusive to them), it would be something else. On top of that, good voice actors are insanely hard to come by in my area (I did a project about 2 years ago with an animated series, and the people that I found in my area were god awful).
And no, it's not the same resolution as the SNES. The SNES has more vertical lines in their similar resolution than the Genesis does. Also, it isn't proper to say "SNES's resolution" since the SNES came out after the Genesis :)
Attachment 3770
Here is an example of the lower resolution. As much as I'd hate to show something in the middle of redesign since we're working on palettes, new/updated tiles, etc., I think it would help this conversation a little better to see the differences between 320x224 and 256x224 resolution. Personally, I think it looks a lot better with a lower resolution. Maybe it's because I'm more familiar with this in the RPG's I love (the Final Fantasy series, Secret of Mana, Illusions of Gaia, Soul Blazer, etc), and it makes me feel like this will help the game be more enjoyable. Just my opinion, so feel free to disagree lol.