Originally Posted by
EclecticGroove
Why would you not talk about HD when talking about current or next gen consoles? It's only a useless conversation when talking about older systems.
And if Nintendo made the SuperNES only display black and white, would you have defended it saying color isn't really needed to enjoy the games? No, probably not. They don't need to support the newest bells and whistles and pack in a thousand extra non gaming features, but they should at least support the basics well enough.
As far as HD not mattering, of course it won't matter to anything not made for HD, or only "made" for HD in the most basic sense of the word. It doesn't mean a better game, but it certainly means a better looking game if used right. And so long as the game is done well, there's no reason it can't also look nice.