Originally Posted by
Splatterhouse5
Hehe...I just knew that you were going to bring up Sonic and Soul Calibur 2. Sonic may as well be a Nintendo IP as it almost seems like the only fanbase that cares for it, which makes it odd that Sonic Generations didn't hit the Wii.
GC's version of SC2 had Link as it's bonus character. It certainly helps that it's a fantastic game without the bonus characters, but throwing Link in there is like throwing Mario in a Kart Racing game, or a wacky sports title - Reasonably fun games in their own right, but eliminate the iconic chracters and you're looking at the kind of sales that 3rd parties were usually dealing with on Nintendo platforms. You don't think that the Mario Party and Mario & Sonic at the Olympics series' sell well because they're good, do you?
You've got a few examples here and there, but the vast majority sold better on the xbox. There were 8 Tom Clancy titles released on the GC that all sold dramatically less than the Xbox versions. In fact, they sold so pathetically (5 of the 8 games couldn't crawl past 80,000 sales worldwide) that it's mystifying that Ubisoft continued to release them on the GC. You can't really say that Nintendo 1st party has a comparable alternative to Tom Clancy games (Splinter Cell, Ghost Recon, Rainbow Six).
All Call of Duty and Medal of Honor games (5 games in total) sold more than twice as well on the xbox. James Bond games seem to be the only gun games that GC owners seemed to like with any consistency, however, only 1 of 5 JB games (From Russia with Love) sold better on the GC.
Just to keep score. 17 of the last 18 3rd party multi-plats that I just rattled off sold better on the similarly selling Xbox, and most of it done in embarrasing fashion.
Wanna take a look at sales for EA sports titles between the two? I know you don't like sports titles, but it's pretty ugly. It's like 30-40 games worth of ugly. Just looking at those differences can start to paint a clearer picture of EA's slow burning frustration with Nintendo.
In fact, besides 1 Need for Speed game, 1 Burnout game, 1 Tony Hawk game, and 2 SSX games (keep in mind there's like 20 games between those series' alone), I don't think there's another 3rd party sports title on both consoles that sold better on the GC. This is A TON of games. Probably over 80 3rd party multi-plats, and I can only find 5 that sold marginally better on the GC. Even the 2 Simpsons driving games sold better on the xbox (oddly enough, the one published by EA sold dramatically worse on the GC).
Without even needing to go any further, it's really hard to argue that Xbox owners didn't support 3rd party games dramatically better than GC owners. I'm certainly not saying that nintendo console owners NEVER buy 3rd party games, but it's easy to see that they don't do it enough, and after 20 years of half-hearted and wildly unpredictable 3rd party sales, I'm certain that developers and publishers have taken notice.