The 100 Greatest Sega Genesis Games of All Time

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OverDrone

That's what I mean, after a certain number (in my case 30), it gets hard to place them in any sort of definitive order since they all feel as good as one another, i.e. very solid. That's the Sega Seal of Quality in action for you ;)

---

Yeah that's basically it. Heck my list doesn't even have any of the Road Rash games (that's 3 games right there), I could probably keep going with "sweet, but I don't play them anymore" till like 150 games.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by chilled

Starflight on 3rd that's quite a statement :)

anyway don't forget in those kind of lists the last place (the 100th game) is usually a hidden gem or something YOU want to be looked at beyond the fact that it's probably not going to make it onto the final list.

I agree with Zebbe: as I said, it's much easier to group our preferences in tiers and the only rank the top-tier ones. Also ranking 32X games amongst MD games seems weird (we are just not used to) as it is somewhat regarded as a different console on its own (that must be planted onto the MD, though...)

---

but starflight and its intro music are so awesome, you have to buy it to believe it, man it is hard compiling a top 100 list

Top five prediction:

1) Sonic 2
2) Streets of Rage 2
3) Gunstar Heroes
4) Sonic 3 & Knuckles
5) Castlevania Bloodlines

Castlevania is not making this top 5 having Contra around. Also no shooters? TFIV man. S3K is trouncing everything anyway.
my guess is S3K, SoR2, GH, TFIV, S2

2 more days to get a list in! THIS IS HAPPENING!!!

Alright. After long deliberation, here is my list. Truthfully, I don't think I've ever played 100 Genesis games - so here are 50 that I have certainly owned, played and enjoyed. Not easy but for the moment I'm settled with the following:


001) Sonic the Hedgehog 2
002) Gunstar Heroes
003) Sonic the Hedgehog 3 & Knuckles
004) Streets of Rage 2
005) Phantasy Star IV
006) Shinobi III: Return of the Ninja Master
007) Monster World IV
008) Castlevania: Bloodlines
009) Rocket Knight Adventures
010) Shining Force II
011) Thunder Force IV
012) Lunar II: Eternal Blue CD
013) Musha Aleste
014) Sonic the Hedgehog
015) Snatcher CD
016) Contra: Hard Corps
017) Dynamite Headdy
018) Vectorman
019) Ristar
020) Pulseman
021) Ecco the Dolphin CD
022) Robo Aleste CD
023) Mega Man: The Wily Wars
024) Ranger-X
025) Sonic the Hedgehog CD
026) Mega Turrican
027) Dr. Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine
028) Alisia Dragoon
029) Popful Mail CD
030) Pier Solar and the Great Architects
031) Crusader of Centy
032) Lunar: Silver Star CD
033) Gley Lancer
034) Alien Soldier
035) Twinkle Tale
036) Panorama Cotton
037) Super Street Fighter II: The New Challengers
038) Virtua Fighter 32X
039) Shadow Squadron 32X
040) Comix Zone
041) Eliminate Down
042) Virtua Racing 32X
043) Battle Mania 2
044) Final Fight CD
045) Splatterhouse 3
046) Silpheed CD
047) Toejam & Earl
048) Shining Force CD
049) Zero Wing
050) Knuckles Chaotix 32X

------------------------------

Honorable Mentions:

051) Android Assault: The Revenge of Bari-Arm CD
052) Ecco the Dolphin: The Tides of Time CD
053) Ghouls 'N Ghosts
054) Sparkster
055) Toejam & Earl in Panic on Funkotron

Sent my list in. I'd be surprised if any of my top 5 are in anyone else's top 10. :)

Just put the finishing touches on my own personal list. I have 100 games, with about 30 more that it really hurt to cut. I did limit myself to just 1 football game even though there were at least 5-6 more that I probably should have included, there just wasn't enough room. Can't wait to tally up the results. Thanks everybody for sending in a list. I will start posting results by the first of August, probably in a separate thread.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by chilled

Castlevania is not making this top 5 having Contra around. Also no shooters? TFIV man. S3K is trouncing everything anyway.
my guess is S3K, SoR2, GH, TFIV, S2

---

TFIV is in my top 5, I'll tell you that much. I erred on the side of caution with that prediction, shooters are never as popular but I could be (hope) i'm wrong!

Turned in 98. I'm sure I could get to 100 easily, but I excluded games superior on other systems (with just a couple of exceptions, primarily for price). I'll post my list after the final tallies. I will give my top 5.

Sonic the Hedgehog 3 & Knuckles
Thunder Force III
Shinobi III
Castle of Illusion
Alien Soldier

These sometimes get rotated. Sometimes Gleylancer sneaks in, or Bloodlines. Road Rash 2 was in there for a while, but it got bumped down to 16.

Here goes my list :)

Note: there are quite some games that I own that would easly make the list, but haven´t played them enough like tf4, gunstar heroes, ristar, golden axe 3, Ayrton Senna smgp 2 etc etc ;)

Must also say that I could easly go with top 200, only needed to play more some titles so I could give them a proper rating...

1 Micro Machines 2
2 Sonic
3 Turtles Hyperstone Heist
4 Sonic 2
5 Story of Thor (beyond oasis)
6 Sonic 3 + Sonic & Knuckles
7 Quackshot
8 Tiny Toons Buster´s hidden treasure
9 Street Fighter 2 S.C Edition
10 World of Illusion
11 Streets Of Rage 2
12 Bare Knuckle 3
13 Micro Machines TT 96
14 Castle of Illusion
15 Golden Axe
16 Streets of Rage
17 Revenge Of Shinobi
18 Shinobi 3
19 Probotector (contra hard corps)
20 Fifa Soccer
21 Nba Jam
22 Aladdin
23 Alien Soldier
24 Golden Axe II
25 Mickeymania
26 Virtua Racing
27 Micro Machines
28 Super Street Fighter 2
29 Desert Strike
30 Road Rash
31 Jungle Strike
32 Sunset riders
33 Batman
34 Street Racer
35 Toe jam and Earl Panic on Funkotron
36 Comix Zone
37 Shadow Dancer
38 Mortal Kombat 2
39 Donald in Maui Mallard
40 Speedball 2
41 Terminator cd
42 Pete Sampras Tennis
43 Micro Machines Military
44 Alien 3
45 Castlevania
46 Mortal Kombat
47 Super Skidmarks
48 Road Rash 2
49 Rocket Knight Adventures
50 Earthworm Jim
51 Psycho Pinball
52 Robocop vs Terminator
53 Super Hang On
54 Mortal Kombat 3
55 WWF Royal Rumble
56 Tiny Toons Acme All Stars
57 World Cup Italia 90
58 Asterix and the Great Rescue
59 Moonwalker
60 Marko´s Magic Football
61 Nhl 95
62 Nba Live 96
63 Super Monaco GP
64 Fifa Soccer 95
65 Olympic Gold
66 Jungle Book
67 Fifa Soccer 96
68 wwf super wrestlemania
69 Lion King
70 Dynamite Headdy
71 Eternal Champions
72 Jurassic Park
73 Mega Bomberman
74 Wimbledon
75 Global Gladiators
76 Earthworm Jim 2
77 Cool Spot
78 Pitfall
79 Last Battle
80 Columms
81 Dragon
82 Sonic 3D
83 Taz Escape from Mars
84 Batman Returns
85 Boogerman
86 Samurai Shodown
87 Turtles Tournament Fighters
88 Toy Story
89 Great Circus Mystery
90 Blattletoads
91 Fifa 97
92 Maximum Carnage
93 Sylvester & Tweety Cagey Capers
94 Tazmania
95 Altered Beast
96 Lotus Turbo Challenge
97 Simpsons Bart vs Space Mutants
98 Greendog
99 The Terminator
100 Fantasia

I managed to come up with about 120 of my favorites over the last few days. Tonight I'll narrow down the list and get them into order. Just in time for the deadline.

This is the final day to get a list in. You have until midnight tonight central US time if anyone wants to get one in. Results will be tallied next week. The level of participation exceeded my expectations. Can not wait to get the numbers and start posting this thing. Thanks again everyone.

BTW Nobi do you have a good way of automating most of this process? Automatic search/replace with tab should let you plop most people's lists straight into a spreadsheet, and a good text editor can number in reverse order (or you could use an Excel formula where points = 101 - list number). I assume you've got something in mind -- just want to make sure you're not giving yourself carpal tunnel for no reason. :)

Since everyone's are in, I'll post mine. I could only get to 98, all Genesis, no Sega CD or 32X. Also, had I added games that were technically good on the Genesis but I preferred to play elsewhere, I easily could have added 25 more. I dropped them out as this is what I want my library to look like.

1. Sonic the Hedgehog 3 & Knuckles
2. Thunder Force III
3. Shinobi III
4. Castle of Illusion
5. Alien Soldier
6. Gleylancer
7. Castlevania Bloodlines
8. Sonic the Hedgehog
9. Thunder Force IV
10. Monster World IV
11. Streets of Rage 2
12. Sonic the Hedgehog 2
13. Crusader of Centy
14. Wonder Boy in Monster World
15. Phantasy Star IV
16. Road Rash 2
17. Ghouls ’n Ghosts
18. Midnight Resistance
19. Gaiares
20. Chiki Chiki Boys
21. Gunstar Heroes
22. MUSHA
23. Earthworm Jim
24. Bio-Hazard Battle
25. Flicky
26. Rocket Knight Adventures
27. Frogger
28. Eliminate Down
29. Flink
30. Sparkster
31. Fire Shark
32. Ecco the Dolphin
33. Pulseman
34. Elemental Master
35. World of Illusion
36. Road Rash
37. Shining Force II
38. Mega Turrican
39. Ranger X
40. Beyond Oasis
41. Golden Axe II
42. Alisia Dragoon
43. Contra Hard Corps (J)
44. Strider
45. Decap Attack
46. TMNT: Hyperstone Heist
47. Dr. Robotnik’s Mean Bean Machine
48. Aladdin
49. Lion King
50. NBA Jam TE
51. Revenge of Shinobi
52. Earthworm Jim 2
53. Alex Kidd in the Enchanted Castle
54. Samurai Shodown
55. Streets of Rage
56. X-Men 2: Clone Wars
57. Hellfire
58. ESWAT
59. Jurassic Park
60. Quackshot
61. Forgotten Worlds
62. Streets of Rage 3 (J)
63. Splatterhouse 2
64. Golden Axe
65. Demolition Man
66. Ristar
67. Ecco the Dolphin 2
68. Shining Force
69. Truxton
70. Comix Zone
71. Verytex
72. Shadow Dancer
73. Phantasy Star II
74. Adventures of Batman and Robin
75. X-Men
76. Dynamite Headdy
77. Pier Solar
78. Splatterhouse 3
79. Wiz N Liz
80. Wings of Wor
81. Tiny Toon Adventures: Buster’s Hidden Treasure
82. Batman Returns
83. Mickey Mania
84. Batman
85. Kid Chameleon
86. Landstalker
87. Fatal Rewind
88. Spider-Man/X-men: Arcade’s Revenge
89. Phelios
90. Jungle Book
91. WWF: Royal Rumble
92. Thunder Force II
93. Mystic Defender
94. NHL 94
95. Shining in the Darkness
96. Phantasy Star III
97. Crüe Ball
98. Sol Deace